OBX

Alright, How about the Outer Banks of North Carolina?
It's an area that few of us, as far as I know, have never been to and is rich in history and right on the Ocean.

Lakecrest Resort, Detroit Lakes, MN

There's also the idea that we don't mess with success -- we could go back to the Lakecrest Resort.

In the Sierras

Also nice --

Caples lake

My dream vacation

Newfoundland!

Burnt cape cabins

Ocean Delight cottages, Whiteaway, Newfoundland. Rates

More ideas -- Manitoulin Island, Ontario; San Juan Islands - Washington

Manitoulin Island, Lake Huron (Ontario)

This looks amazing! Here's the wikipedia article. 


San Juan Islands, Washington

Isle Royale

Chris is forcing me to post this: Chris wants to go to an island in a lake that has lakes in the island, so there's this.

And the view from outer space.

Minnesota -- Boundary waters?

What do people think about Minnesota, but a bit further north?


Some resorts listed here.

This one, Ludlow's Island Resort on Lake vermillion, is on an island. (Go look at the website. It's beautiful.)

This, Pine Point Lodge on Crane lake,  is on a peninsula and may be cheaper -- lots of nice waterfront cabins.

Here's a place with  cabins near Ely, on farm lake -- rates seem reasonable. Possibility for trips into the Boundary waters --

although, also the possibilty for hanging around at the lake. Rates seem quite reasonable.